The Springfield Three (Sherrill Levitt, Suzie Streeter, Stacy McCall) Disappearance and Unsolved Mystery
The Springfield Three refers to the unsolved 1992 disappearance of Sherrill Levitt, her daughter Suzie Streeter, and Suzie's friend Stacy McCall from their home in Springfield, Missouri. The three women vanished without a trace on June 7, 1992, leaving behind personal belongings, keys, and cars, but no clear evidence of what happened.
To this day, the case remains one of the most baffling missing persons investigations in the United States. The sudden and unexplained loss of Sherrill Levitt, Suzie Streeter, and Stacy McCall continues to raise questions and fuel efforts to find answers.
Key Figures Involved
Sherrill Levitt, Suzie Streeter, and Stacy McCall are known collectively as the Springfield Three. Their disappearances on June 7, 1992, remain one of the most discussed unsolved cases in Missouri, involving a tight-knit circle of family and friends suddenly lost without a trace.
Sherrill Levitt
Sherrill Levitt was 47 years old at the time she went missing. She worked as a cosmetologist and was known for her reliability and dedication to her daughter, Suzie Streeter. Sherrill owned the home at 1717 East Delmar Street, the site from which all three women vanished.
She was last seen the day before the disappearance and spoke to a friend on the phone late that night. There were no signs of forced entry or struggle in the house, and her personal belongings—including her purse, keys, and car—were left behind. Sherrill was described as responsible, making her sudden disappearance especially troubling for investigators and family.
Suzie Streeter
Suzie Streeter, age 19, was Sherrill Levitt’s daughter. She had just graduated from Kickapoo High School that evening and planned to spend the night at her mother’s home with her friend Stacy McCall after attending several graduation parties. Suzie was last reported seen leaving her friend’s house to return to her own.
She was described as outgoing and independent. Friends and family recall that she had clear plans for her future and was close with her mother. Suzie’s belongings, including her personal effects and car, were also left at the house. She and Sherrill had a strong relationship, which added to the confusion surrounding both their abrupt disappearance.
Stacy McCall
Stacy McCall was 18 years old, also a recent Kickapoo High School graduate. She had planned to stay the night with Suzie after a series of graduation events but vanished along with Suzie and Sherrill from Sherrill’s home. Born on April 23, 1974, Stacy was known as a responsible and cautious young woman who was looking forward to college.
Her parents became concerned when Stacy did not return home or contact anyone, prompting the initial missing persons report. Stacy’s purse, keys, and other personal items were left at the house, and her car was parked outside. There was no evidence to suggest Stacy intended to leave or run away. The abrupt loss of contact with her family and friends remains a key element of the case.
Timeline of Events
Sherrill Levitt, Suzie Streeter, and Stacy McCall vanished without a trace in Springfield, Missouri in June 1992. The events leading up to and following their disappearance provide a detailed, time-specific look at one of Missouri’s most well-known unsolved cases.
Graduation Night
On June 6, 1992, Suzie Streeter and Stacy McCall graduated from Kickapoo High School in Springfield. They attended several graduation parties that evening with friends and classmates. Originally, the girls planned to stay overnight at a hotel in Branson and visit a water park the next day, but those plans changed at the last minute.
Instead, close to 2:00 a.m. on June 7, Streeter and McCall decided to stay at Streeter's home, where she lived with her mother, Sherrill Levitt, at 1717 East Delmar Street. They arrived at the house together sometime after leaving their last party. This marked the last confirmed sighting of all three women, as neighbors and friends did not see them after that night.
Events of June 7, 1992
The morning of June 7 was when the disappearance became apparent. Friends who had planned to meet Streeter and McCall at a local water park were unable to reach them. Calls and visits to the house went unanswered, and no one responded to knocks at the door.
Inside the house, Sherrill Levitt’s, Suzie Streeter’s, and Stacy McCall’s personal belongings—including purses, car keys, and clothing—were found undisturbed. The family dog was still in the home. There was no clear sign of a struggle or forced entry, although a porch globe light was shattered in front of the home, possibly indicating some disturbance near the entrance.
The women’s cars remained parked outside the house. Despite this, there were no immediate signs of where they had gone or if foul play was involved. This sudden absence with all their possessions left behind raised immediate concerns among family and friends.
Initial Discovery
By the afternoon of June 7, after repeated attempts to make contact, more friends and relatives arrived at the Delmar Street house. They entered through an unlocked door and found the house eerily quiet, with nothing obviously out of place apart from the missing women.
A fragmented glass globe from the porch light lay outside, but aside from this minor damage, police found little evidence. Several people who entered the home accidentally disturbed possible crime scene evidence before the Springfield Police Department was called.
Officers soon classified the situation as a missing persons case involving all three women. Despite investigations, searches, and media coverage, there were no substantial leads as to what had happened. The sudden vanishing of three women from a quiet Springfield neighborhood gave rise to ongoing speculation about possible abduction and foul play.
Investigation and Search Efforts
Efforts to locate Sherrill Levitt, Suzie Streeter, and Stacy McCall quickly became one of the largest missing persons investigations in Springfield, Missouri. Law enforcement, the community, and the media all played active roles as the case evolved into a long-term cold case without closure.
Springfield Police Department Response
The Springfield Police Department initiated the investigation on June 7, 1992, after receiving reports that the three women had disappeared from Levitt’s home. Officers found no immediate signs of forced entry. Their purses, keys, and other personal items were left behind, indicating the women left abruptly or were taken against their will.
Within hours, police coordinated with other local agencies to expand their search. They conducted interviews with friends, relatives, and neighbors. The department processed the scene and canvassed the area seeking leads, but the case quickly grew more complex due to the lack of clear suspects or witnesses.
Authorities worked with Crime Stoppers and issued public alerts, following up on hundreds of tips. Despite efforts to investigate all potential avenues, there was no confirmed sighting or major breakthrough that led to the women’s whereabouts.
Physical Evidence Collected
Investigators documented several items left at the Levitt residence, including the women's personal belongings. A broken porch lamp was discovered, which some thought could indicate a struggle, but police later stated it might have been accidental or unrelated to the case.
There were no signs of violence, forced entry, or significant disturbance in the home. Authorities dusted for fingerprints but did not recover any that could be conclusively linked to a suspect. The lack of physical evidence made it difficult to reconstruct events or identify what had occurred after the trio entered the house.
Police collected the women's vehicles from the property. Forensic examinations did not reveal any clear connections to a perpetrator. The evidence, or lack thereof, proved to be a significant barrier to progress in the investigation.
Community and Media Involvement
The mysterious disappearance quickly attracted regional and national attention. The Kansas City Star and other media outlets regularly covered developments, keeping the case in the public eye. Vigils and community gatherings were organized to support the families and maintain momentum in the search efforts.
Volunteers participated in search parties, distributed flyers, and coordinated with police. Community members also contributed to reward funds aiming to generate new leads. Crime Stoppers continued to receive tips years after the incident, showing ongoing public investment in resolving the case.
Despite these efforts, the case remains unsolved. The collective response demonstrated solidarity but has not yet provided the closure families continue to seek.
Major Theories and Suspects
Investigators and true crime researchers have examined several key figures and theories in the unsolved case of the Springfield Three. Foul play is strongly suspected, given the absence of any evidence pointing to voluntary disappearance or accidental death.
Robert Craig Cox
Robert Craig Cox is one of the most discussed suspects among law enforcement and the public. A convicted kidnapper and robber, Cox was living in Springfield at the time the women vanished in June 1992. He was known for his violent criminal history and proximity to the case.
Cox told reporters and police he knew the women were dead and claimed they would never be found. He was questioned by authorities but never charged. Cox later recanted some statements, increasing speculation about his involvement.
His criminal background, combined with his ominous comments and refusal to provide clear answers, has led many to view Cox as a credible suspect. Law enforcement remains interested in him, but no physical evidence has ever connected him directly to the scene.
Bartt Streeter
Bartt Streeter, Suzie Streeter’s brother, found himself under suspicion partly due to circumstances leading up to the disappearances. He had a strained relationship with both his sister and mother, reportedly leading to arguments the previous year. Bartt also faced charges of public intoxication in the months prior.
Despite this tension, police found no physical evidence linking Bartt to the missing women. He moved away from Springfield shortly after the disappearance, which brought further scrutiny.
Over the years, Bartt has cooperated with law enforcement and consistently denied any involvement. Investigators have publicly cleared him as a suspect, but his connection to the family continues to generate discussion within the true crime community.
Possible Serial Killers
The theory that the Springfield Three might have been victims of a serial killer or killers has persisted for decades. Observers point to the lack of evidence at the scene, the apparent speed and efficiency of the crime, and similarities to other kidnapping cases in the region during the late 1980s and early 1990s.
Several serial offenders were active in the Midwest during this time, leading to speculation about connections between these cases. There was, however, no direct evidence tying known serial killers to the disappearance.
Law enforcement considered this possibility, but no arrests have been made. The serial killer theory remains largely circumstantial, relying on patterns, timelines, and the absence of alternative explanations.
Notable Locations
Several locations stand out in the case of The Springfield Three, influencing events and timelines. Each place holds unique relevance, from where the women vanished to settings linked to their final known movements.
Sherrill Levitt's Home
Address: 1717 E. Delmar Street, Springfield, Missouri
Coordinates: 37°11′41″N 93°15′47″W
This house was the last verified location of Sherrill Levitt, Suzie Streeter, and Stacy McCall. The women disappeared here in the early hours of June 7, 1992. Authorities found their personal belongings inside, including purses, keys, and cars, which appeared untouched.
No signs of forced entry or struggle were detected. Neighbors reported nothing unusual that night. The porch light globe was shattered, but otherwise, the house looked normal.
Investigators believe something significant happened inside or just outside the home. It remains the focal point for law enforcement efforts and media coverage, symbolizing the unresolved nature of the case.
Kickapoo High School
Kickapoo High School in Springfield, Missouri, played a central role for the two younger women. Both Suzie Streeter and Stacy McCall graduated from Kickapoo on the day before they went missing.
Graduation date: June 6, 1992
The school's commencement ceremonies marked their last day as students. After graduation, they attended multiple parties with other classmates before heading to Suzie’s home. The graduation itself was a point of celebration, but it also set the sequence of events that led to their vanishing.
Many interviews and searches focused on friends and acquaintances from the school. The connection to Kickapoo ties the missing women to a particular community and moment in time, making it a crucial reference point in understanding the timeline.
Cox South Hospital
Cox South Hospital is located in Springfield and was referenced during the initial investigation. Stacy McCall’s mother, Janis, reached out to Cox South and other area hospitals on June 7 when she was unable to contact her daughter.
She hoped to determine if any of the women had been admitted, possibly due to an accident or medical emergency. The searches yielded no results, with hospital staff able to confirm none of the three had checked in or been treated.
Though the hospital had no direct involvement, its role highlights the family's immediate and methodical response to the disappearance. Checking emergency rooms is a common step in missing persons cases, as it helps rule out sudden incidents in the local area, including Springfield and the broader Ozarks region.
Ongoing Mystery and Public Awareness
Interest in the unsolved disappearance of Sherrill Levitt, Suzie Streeter, and Stacy McCall continues to shape public discussion and inspire outreach efforts. Media coverage, documentaries, podcasts, and community action have all kept attention focused on this cold case.
Role of the Media
The media has played an essential role in keeping the Springfield Three case in public view. Outlets such as the Kansas City Star and local television have provided regular updates, especially on anniversaries of the disappearance.
News coverage often highlights ongoing leads, interviews with law enforcement, and reflections from family members. Media attention also influences public opinion and encourages tips to police.
Journalists maintain pressure for continued investigation. This visibility remains critical in cold cases to prevent them from fading from public memory.
True Crime Podcasts and Documentaries
True crime podcasts have brought new attention to the Springfield Three. Notably, Anne Roderique-Jones launched a podcast focused entirely on this case, examining evidence and gathering interviews with investigators and those close to the families.
Podcasts often break down timelines, present new theories, and revisit witness accounts. They have created discussions across social media platforms, further expanding public interest.
Documentaries, both televised and online, use visual storytelling to engage wider audiences. Many of these productions feature detailed reconstructions, expert interviews, and fresh appeals for information.
Community Advocacy and Vigils
Community advocacy has remained strong since 1992. Annual vigils are organized in Springfield to honor Sherrill Levitt, Suzie Streeter, and Stacy McCall, drawing local residents and supporters.
These events give families and friends a space to remember their loved ones. They also remind the public about the lack of closure and the need for information.
Local organizations and advocates distribute flyers, host awareness events, and maintain social media pages. Continued community efforts keep the case alive and encourage anyone with knowledge to come forward.
Impact on Springfield and Beyond
The disappearance of Sherrill Levitt, Suzie Streeter, and Stacy McCall in 1992 had a direct effect on personal security, law enforcement, and how families in Springfield approached safety and uncertainty. The case drew attention across the Ozarks and has affected many aspects of daily life.
Changes in Safety Practices
After June 7, 1992, many residents in Springfield quickly adopted new security measures. Homeowners installed additional locks, purchased alarm systems, and changed habits such as leaving doors unlocked or walking alone at night. Law enforcement in the Ozarks also increased public outreach on personal safety.
Parents across Springfield became more cautious, especially about letting teenagers stay out late or attend unsupervised gatherings. Community watch programs grew, and schools began discussing safety protocols more openly. These changes reflected a city—previously viewed as relatively safe—becoming more vigilant.
The case contributed to ongoing discussions about missing persons and inspired updates in how police handle similar investigations. As a result, Springfield's perception of everyday risk shifted, with residents continuing to prioritize safety decades later.
Long-Term Effects on Families
For the families of Levitt, Streeter, and McCall, the lack of closure has caused persistent grief. The ongoing uncertainty prevents them from finding peace or moving forward fully. Each anniversary is marked by renewed media attention and fresh reminders of their loss.
Family members have worked to keep the case in the public eye through interviews, memorials, and partnerships with organizations focused on missing persons. This ongoing effort is both a way to seek answers and to support others enduring similar losses.
The disappearance also impacted broader family networks throughout the Ozarks. It changed how families communicate about safety and share concerns—especially in the absence of closure—leaving lasting scars for those closest to the Springfield Three.
