Residents of Talina have long shared stories about unusual creatures roaming the surrounding woods. Reports describe encounters with large, upright animals resembling giant coyotes or hairy beasts that walk on two legs, sparking curiosity and fear within the community. The Green Hill Monster is one such entity, linked to a series of unsettling incidents in the early 1970s.

A particularly notable encounter involved a group of high school students who, while out in the woods, experienced a frightening and unexplained event near Green Hill Road. Their accounts, matched with disturbing discoveries in the area soon after, prompted both official investigation and local speculation. These stories have left a lasting mark on Talina, raising questions about what really lurks in its forests.

Key Takeaways

Talina has a history of strange creature sightings in its wooded areas.
The 1971 Green Hill Monster event involved credible witnesses and official inquiry.
Rumors and evidence from these encounters continue to affect the community.

Overview of Talina’s Mysterious Creatures

Reports from Talina tell of unusual, upright-walking animals, drawing the attention of both locals and investigators. Among these, sightings have included a massive, two-legged coyote and a creature locals refer to as the Green Hill Monster. Several encounters have been linked to the dense woods and backroads around the area.

Notable Incidents:

In the early 1970s, a well-known sighting involved local high school students who encountered a large, hairy figure on two legs near Green Hill Road.
Witnesses shared their experiences with law enforcement, who responded but declined to confirm anything unusual.
The Green Hill Monster is frequently mentioned in Bigfoot databases, though dates of the encounters are sometimes misreported.

Key Details:

Year Description Reported By Notable Details 1970s 7ft upright coyote sighting Local woman Walked on two legs 1971 Hairy, upright creature sighting Football players Encounter followed by animal mutilations 1971 Green Hill Monster encounter Multiple students, teacher Found deer killed with broken necks

Following these events, several animals—both cattle and deer—were discovered mutilated close to the original sighting locations. Examinations found no bullet wounds, and the injuries suggested immense force consistent with powerful predators.

Students and community members returned to search the area by daylight, finding broken fences and unexplained animal remains, but never the creatures themselves. The individuals who reported these events were considered credible by investigation teams, giving weight to the claims despite the lack of physical evidence.

Reports of the Green Hill Creature

1970 Incident Involving Dusty Rhodes

In the fall of 1970, Dusty Rhodes was hunting near Tahlequah when he claimed to encounter a large, upright, hairy figure in the woods. After his report, a series of unexplained cattle mutilations occurred on a nearby ranch. According to locals, these events took place within about a mile of each other and were soon associated with what would be called the “Green Hill Creature.”

1971 High School Football Team Experience

Location: Near Green Hill Road, 5 miles southeast of Tahlequah
Date: October 1971

After an evening pep rally, Talina High School football players decided to look for a secluded place along Green Hill Road. The group built a fire, and one player, identified as E.S., wandered off and was suddenly grabbed from behind. E.S. was visibly shaken and retreated to the vehicle, locking himself inside. Another team member, E.N., used a spotlight to investigate and saw a large, hairy, bipedal animal approximately 20 feet away.

Key Details:

Athletic teammates and a teacher later visited the site in daylight.
Three deer were found nearby, all with broken necks and their guts removed but no bullet wounds.
Official response from law enforcement was unusually guarded, advising the group to leave the area.

Witness Reaction E.S. Shocked, refused to leave vehicle E.N. Visibly disturbed, left area immediately Other witnesses Searched site, found deceased deer

Errors in Bigfoot Database Records

Several Bigfoot databases have mistakenly labeled the 1971 sighting as occurring in 1970. This confusion likely arises from the proximity and similarity of the Dusty Rhodes report the previous year. A witness who contacted the BFRO clarified the date and provided detailed information, helping to correct the public record.

Note: The BFRO investigator who followed up regarded the witness as highly credible, due in part to his local reputation and professional experience.

Specifics of the 1971 Green Hill Road Case

High School Players’ Unexpected Nighttime Encounter

On a foggy night in October 1971, a group of students from a local high school, including several football team members, drove out to a wooded area just off Green Hill Road. After starting a fire and settling in, one student, identified only as "E.S.," separated from the group momentarily. He was startled when a large, upright, furry creature reportedly emerged and made contact with him from behind.

Panicked, E.S. ran back to the clearing, bypassing his teammates and locking himself inside a vehicle. Unsure of what had happened, another student, "E.N.," grabbed a spotlight and began scanning the woods. When E.N. saw a sizable, bipedal animal standing nearby, he too fled, filled with fear, prompting others to quickly pile into their vehicles and head back to town.

Initial Responses Among Students and Staff

Upon returning, the football players appeared visibly shaken, seeking out a teacher and other classmates at a barn where preparations for a school event were underway. Witnesses recalled E.S. being pale and in shock, refusing to get out of the vehicle, while E.N. trembled uncontrollably. Initially, some believed the two boys might be playing a joke, but their distress seemed genuine.

The group decided to investigate further. Several students and the teacher organized a convoy and drove back to Green Hill Road, aiming to see or uncover any evidence of the creature.

Law Enforcement Arrival and Subsequent Steps

As the students returned to the site in multiple vehicles, local police noticed the unusual activity, which led to the involvement of highway patrol and a county deputy. Officers asked the students about their presence and listened to E.S. and E.N. describe their frightening experiences.

The two law enforcement officers briefly searched the woods but came back after a short time. They advised the group to leave, making comments that struck the students as odd and refusing either to confirm or deny any findings. The students took the officers' advice and returned to town.

Discovery the Next Day:

Follow-Up Visit: The next day, a group of named students revisited the site in daylight.
Findings: On the north side of the road (the woods), they found three deer with broken necks and their entrails removed. The animals were otherwise intact, with no bullet wounds.
Examination: A student familiar with hunting investigated and confirmed there were no gunshot injuries—only broken necks and ripped-out guts.
No Tracks: No footprints or animal tracks were visible in the area.

Summary Table: Key Individuals & Events

Person Role/Nature of Involvement Behavior/Observation E.S. Football player/witness Shock, would not leave vehicle E.N. Football player/witness Terrified, trembling, saw creature Students/Staff Investigators (night and daytime) Found remains, saw nothing else Police Responders Searched, acted oddly, suggested leaving

The events remain a subject of discussion locally, with participants recalling both the strange wildlife evidence and the unusual police response.

Troubling Findings Around the Encounter Site

Unusual Livestock Injuries

After reports of an upright, hairy creature in the Talina area, several cows were discovered on a nearby ranch displaying severe and unexplained injuries. These incidents occurred less than a mile from where the reported encounter took place. The condition of the cattle—particularly the damage—could not be easily attributed to known animal attacks or typical causes found in the region.

A summary of key details:

Date Location Observation Fall 1971 Talina-area ranch Cattle mutilations ~1 mile from Encounter Site Severe injuries noted

Deer Remains Discovered

A group of students who revisited the area in daylight found three deer with broken necks and abdominal cavities torn open. None of the animals appeared to have been shot, as no bullet wounds were present and their bodies were otherwise undamaged except for the missing guts. The group searched for tracks but found none in the grass surrounding the remains.

List of findings at the site:

Three deer with broken necks
Intact bodies except for the removed organs
No bullet holes
No detectable tracks nearby

These discoveries added a disturbing layer to the events following the reported creature sighting, raising questions about the circumstances and cause of the animal deaths.

Reliability Assessment and Inquiry

BFRO Fieldwork and Follow-Up

A report was submitted to the Bigfoot Field Researchers Organization (BFRO) regarding the incident near Green Hill Road. An investigator from the BFRO personally communicated with witnesses and reviewed the details of the encounter, the subsequent reactions, and evidence found at the scene. The investigator noted unusual behavior from the local law enforcement officers who were present at the site, which added to the intrigue surrounding the incident.

Key Steps in the Follow-Up:

Step Description Witness Interview Gathered firsthand accounts from those involved Law Enforcement Talk Noted reactions of local police and highway patrol officers Evidence Check Examined area for tracks and physical remains

The BFRO investigator expressed confidence in the main witness’s credibility and believed that the findings were consistent with the reported encounter.

Background of the Main Witness

The primary witness is recognized as a Vietnam veteran and state employee, attributes that contributed to the credibility assessment. Due to his status in the community and wishes for privacy, further details about his identity were withheld.

He is experienced with hunting and wildlife, which provided context for his evaluation of the physical evidence found, including the deer carcasses. According to the investigator, people familiar in the region could vouch for his honesty and reliability.

Witness Credibility Checklist

Military Service: Vietnam veteran
Occupation: State employee
Community Standing: Widely known and respected locally
Privacy: Requested anonymity
Relevant Skills: Experienced hunter

Hypothesis Linking the Entity to Sasquatch

Physical evidence found near the encounter site included deer remains with broken necks and entrails removed, but no bullet wounds or obvious human interference. This suggested the possibility of large animal activity.

The BFRO investigator considered a possible connection between these deer kills and the sighting of the upright, hairy figure. It was proposed that this evidence might point toward a Sasquatch-like creature being present in the vicinity the night before.

Summary Table: Evidence and Explanation

Evidence Found Possible Explanation Three deer carcasses with no shots Large predator, potentially Sasquatch-related No footprints in grass Unknown, complicates animal identification Broken necks, guts removed Unusual predation (not typical for local fauna)

This line of reasoning informed the hypothesis that the so-called Green Hill Monster could be linked to traditional descriptions of Sasquatch, at least in terms of behavior and physical impact on local wildlife.

Enduring Effects within the Talina Area

Reports of upright, hairy creatures in the Talina region—especially those involving the Green Hill monster—left a lasting impression on the local community. These incidents generated significant conversations among students, ranchers, and law enforcement. The football team's late-night encounter became a central topic at school and prompted day-time visits by concerned students to the reported site.

Key Outcomes Noted:

Heightened sense of caution in local woods, especially around Green Hill Road
Increased gatherings to discuss and investigate the events
Unusual animal deaths, such as cattle mutilations and deer found with broken necks, sparked debates about possible causes

Witness Reaction E.S. and E.N. Shock, reluctance to leave vehicle Other students Skepticism turned to concern after witness talk Law enforcement officers Advised group to leave, displayed odd behavior

Locals also noted lingering unease, with some residents reevaluating their outdoor routines. The presence of unexplained animal deaths near the encounter site contributed to ongoing speculation and conversation throughout the Talina community.

The Green Hill Monster: Terrifying Cryptid Encounters in Talina's Haunted Woods