What's REALLY Below New England's Lake Champlain?
There’s a place you won’t find on any standard map—a region existing between the boundaries of the known and the unknowable. It’s a land where history blurs with myth, and the ordinary transforms into the extraordinary. Welcome to New England, as revealed through the haunted tales, legends, and living folklore of the celebrated podcast and TV series “Things Visible and Invisible.” Whether you’re drawn by curiosity, nostalgia, or a deep love for mystery, this journey through New England’s shadows offers more than just ghost stories—it reminds us why legends persist and why our fascination with the unknown endures.
A Land Teeming with Legends
New England’s storybook charm hides a complex tapestry of half-told legends, haunted hills, and secret rivers. It straddles a line between fact and myth, enticing believers and skeptics alike. From ghostly apparitions to unexplained lake monsters and urban folklore, this storied region has become an inspiration for writers, adventurers, and seekers of the strange for centuries.
The Tale of Champ: America’s Own Lake Monster
No recounting of New England’s mysteries would be complete without delving into the legend of Champ, Lake Champlain’s answer to the Loch Ness Monster. Covering the border between Vermont and New York and stretching into Canada, Lake Champlain is vast—only the Great Lakes surpass its size in the U.S. Its waters have spawned legends since the days of Samuel de Champlain, who heard of a massive serpent-like creature from Native Americans during the 1600s.
The descriptions are as consistent as they are eerie: imagine a 150-foot serpent, as wide as a barrel, with a head like a horse, only without ears, rearing above the water before slipping silently beneath the surface. Sightings date back centuries, continuing to present day. There’s a monument on the New York shore inscribed with 80 or 90 names—people who’ve boldly claimed to have seen Champ, some sharing their encounters with a matter-of-fact clarity that leaves skeptics questioning their own disbelief.
Champ sightings are so integral to local culture that the city of Burlington, Vermont, adopted the lake monster as their baseball team’s mascot, and statues, plush toys, and t-shirts abound. And while some may suspect a tourist cash-in, the persistence of new reports, combined with occasional tantalizing photographs and unexplained wakes in the water, keep curiosity alive. Scientists have combed the lake with sonar and underwater cameras, but the mystery remains unresolved. As one local put it, even skeptics find themselves peering at the lake, unable to resist the allure that something undiscovered may still swim beneath those deep waters.
Legend vs. Evidence: What Do We Really Know?
Skeptics point out that scientific inquiry—sonar scans, archival research, and careful analysis—has yet to yield proof of Champ’s existence. Yet, the sheer number of independent eyewitness accounts, old newspaper clippings, and persistent local tales make it difficult to dismiss the legend outright. Consider, too, other regional serpentine monsters, like the Gloucester Sea Serpent of Massachusetts—a century-old tale that’s faded as much as its supposed food sources, but which once enraptured towns along the coast.
With Champ, as with other legendary creatures, the question often becomes: do we even want an answer? As one interviewee mused, the day Champ is definitively proven or debunked, a little of the magic might vanish. Part of what nourishes such legends is their ability to remain unsolved—to keep hope, wonder, and curiosity alive.
A Landscape Gestating Mystery
While southern New England is famous for its dense cities and quaint towns, the north is a sprawling wilderness. Maine, for instance, is largely uninhabited save for its ragged coastline and a few small towns. Its untouched forests, fierce winters, and rugged terrain foster a culture of resilience—and fertile ground for mystery.
Local charm and grit shape more than just tall tales. Take Woodstock, Maine, for instance—the site of America’s last crank phone call system, heroically maintained by its residents until as late as 1981. While the world marched toward keypad phones and instant connections, Woodstock’s citizens resisted change, clinging to their beloved hand-cranked devices. The town now commemorates its technological tenacity with a statue—a fitting tribute to the stubbornness and independence that also foster great legends.
From Urban Legends to City Lore
But New England’s mysteries aren’t all rural. Head south to New York City, and you’ll find legends thriving in the city’s tangled alleys and ancient buildings. Take the tale of Bloody Mary, for example—a chilling story told at sleepovers, where reciting her name in a mirror is said to summon her disfigured spirit. Rational adults may scoff, but even the most skeptical feel a flicker of doubt when staring into a darkened mirror with only a flickering candle for company. These stories linger, not necessarily because they’re real in a literal sense, but because they tap into deep, primal parts of our psyche that revel in the ‘what if.’
Boston, too, has its own living legend—the “Green Monster” of Fenway Park. This imposing outfield wall isn’t just baseball folklore; it’s a city-wide icon and team mascot, personified and celebrated in a way that blurs the line between tangible structure and legendary being. New Englanders take pride in these stories—quirky, haunting, and all their own.
Why Do These Legends Endure?
What ties all these stories together—from lake monsters to haunted stadium walls and mirrors that might just house a vengeful spirit—is our inherent need for stories. Legends flourish wherever people gather, live, and share. The region’s dense weave of history, culture, and hardship creates the perfect climate for enduring tales. Even the simplest among us can, at times, become a part of these myths—just by showing up, asking questions, and daring to believe.
If you’re drawn to the unknown, New England is an unmatched playground for your curiosity—a place where even skeptics lower their guard and wonder what might be lurking just out of sight. The charm of its towns, the vastness of its wild places, and the imaginative fire of its people all combine to make these legends more than stories—they become part of the region’s identity.
Conclusion: Keep the Legend Alive
Perhaps the real draw of New England is not the certainty of its mysteries, but the invitation to participate in them. You can visit the lake and scan the horizon for Champ. You can question locals or brave a Bloody Mary summoning in your own home. You can visit Woodstock and imagine a world before modern convenience. In New England, you’re not just hearing stories—you’re becoming part of them.
So next time you wander through a foggy New England town or stroll along a shadowed lake, remember: you are in a region alive with invisible threads, stories waiting for new voices, and wonders that thrive—both because of and in spite of skepticism. The legend survives because we keep looking, keep questioning, and keep telling the tales ourselves.
📕 Guest: Jeff Belanger
Jeff is an author, podcaster, storyteller, and explorer of the unexplained. He’s written more than a dozen books published in six languages, hosts and produces the Emmy-nominated New England Legends series on PBS and Amazon Prime, and co-hosts the New England Legends podcast. For over 25 years, Jeff has investigated ghosts, monsters, and mysteries, sharing New England’s strangest stories with audiences worldwide.
🌍 Websites:
https://ournewenglandlegends.com/
👍 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ExploringLegends
📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/exploringlegends/
▶️ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@LegendTripping
