Cryptids across the USA? Cryptozoologist Tells All!

The world is full of mysteries. From spine-tingling tales told by the fireside to headline-grabbing newspaper stories, stories of strange creatures have persisted across generations and cultures. But are these tales simply products of wild imagination and folklore, or could there be truth hiding just out of sight, waiting to step into the light? This was the key question explored in a riveting conversation with Jason Offutt, author and journalist, on an episode of “Things Visible and Invisible.”

The Allure of the Unknown

There’s something irresistibly compelling about the unknown. Whether it’s the legendary Loch Ness Monster or the shadowy figure of Bigfoot, tales of cryptids — creatures unknown to science — stir a primal mixture of fear, excitement, and wonder. Jason Offutt, a respected journalist and author of several books on the paranormal, describes how he’s collected hundreds of stories of mysterious beasts across North America. His research isn’t just confined to contemporary sources. Instead, he explores deep into the past, finding examples of monster stories in ancient mythologies from every corner of the globe. Dragons in Asia, the Piasa of America’s Midwest, Bigfoot or Sasquatch among Native American and First Nations people — every culture seems to have its own legends of the unknown.

Yet, Offutt is quick to note, cryptozoology isn't a modern invention. While the term itself may have only come into use in the 1950s, the practice of recording and analyzing stories of unknown creatures stretches back thousands of years. Early texts, from Greek and Babylonian records to manuscripts from ancient Egypt, often described creatures that sound mythical to our ears — and yet, some of these were later proven to exist.

Fact Versus Folklore: Where Science Meets Legends

The enduring skepticism surrounding cryptozoology is understandable. Humans are hardwired to seek explanations for things they don’t understand. In the past, myth filled in gaps. Today, in the age of science, we demand evidence. Jason Offutt embodies this balance: he loves a good story, but he approaches every tale with a scientific mindset, seeking out hard facts behind the folklore.

Among the most compelling arguments for the plausibility of cryptids are examples where legends were validated by science. Offutt recounts several such discoveries: the Corsican “cat fox,” long believed to be a myth, was recently identified as a distinct species; the Bili ape of the Congo, once scoffed at by Western scientists, matched local descriptions for generations before its existence was confirmed; and perhaps most famously, the coelacanth, a fish thought to have been extinct for millions of years, was discovered alive off the African coast in the 1930s.

Even within North America, tales of monsters aren’t just campfire fodder. The infamous Jersey Devil, whose origins are rooted in colonial history, continues to generate sightings today. “Dogmen” — bipedal, wolf-like creatures — pop up in eyewitness accounts from the U.S. to Europe. And in Missouri, Momo the Monster terrorized the town of Louisiana in the 1970s with encounters so convincing that residents, police, and local journalists alike took the matter seriously.

Debunking and Documenting: The Hoaxes and the Hopeful

Of course, not all stories stand up to scrutiny. Some infamous photographs and so-called discoveries have been revealed as hoaxes, perpetuated by pranksters or true believers with more enthusiasm than evidence. These fabrications, like the “surgeon’s photo” of Loch Ness or phony Bigfoot sightings, have muddied the waters, making real investigation more challenging. Offutt points out how even the media can exacerbate this skepticism, often treating paranormal subjects as little more than silly-season filler.

Still, Offutt maintains that there’s enough credible, physical evidence out there to keep the investigations going, citing things like undebunked footprint casts with dermal ridges or DNA samples that show human signatures with “anomalies.” These suggest a creature similar to humans but not quite us — perhaps kindred species standing just outside the bounds of mainstream science.

Why Do These Stories Endure?

Why are we so fascinated by creatures that straddle the line between the known and the unknown? Offutt suggests that it’s the excitement of mystery itself, the ancient instinct that makes us both fear and thrill at what we cannot explain. The strongest emotions, after all, are stirred by what we can’t see: the shadow just beyond the reach of the campfire, the ripple beneath the lake’s surface, the haunting call in the night.

But fascination can sometimes tip into blind faith. Offutt warns against becoming a “true believer” without evidence, urging open-minded skepticism and a thirst for research. He points out that even stories that sound outlandish on the surface — chupacabras draining livestock, rumors of dragons, or alligators in the sewers — often originate from real but misunderstood phenomena before morphing into modern myths.

The Importance of Listening and Learning

Offutt’s final advice is clear: Listen to the locals. History has shown that dismissing indigenous and folk knowledge simply because it hadn’t yet been validated by “modern” science has led to missed discoveries. The Komodo dragon, mountain gorilla, and giant panda were all once considered travelers’ tales or outright fabrications. Now, they grace science books and nature documentaries.

Conclusion: Keep Asking, Keep Exploring

The world remains full of mysteries. Whether every legend of monsters, ghosts, or hidden beasts will one day match a scientific discovery remains to be seen. But Offutt’s balanced approach — loving the story but demanding the evidence — is a lesson for us all.

It’s a reminder that while skepticism is healthy, so is curiosity. As long as unexplored wilderness remains, as long as the heart stirs at old stories of the unexplained, there will always be new mysteries to chase. Maybe, just maybe, one of those legends is waiting to be proven true. Until then, keep your eyes open, your mind sharp, and your sense of wonder alive.

If you’ve enjoyed this journey into the world of the unknown, subscribe to “Things Visible and Invisible,” and join a community of seekers and storytellers. Who knows? Your own story might just be the next great discovery.

📕 Guest: Jason Offutt

Jason is a journalist, novelist, and acclaimed cryptozoologist from Missouri. He teaches journalism at Northwest Missouri State University and is the author of several respected books on the paranormal, including 'Haunted Missouri', 'Chasing American Monsters', and 'Chasing North American Monsters. Jason’s work, blending hard evidence with local legend, has been featured on major radio shows and podcasts like Coast to Coast AM.

🌍 Website: www.jasonoffutt.com

🐦 X: @TheJasonOffutt https://x.com/TheJasonOffutt

👍 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheJasonOffuttAuthor/

📸 Instagram: @offuttjason https://www.instagram.com/thejasonoffutt/